Hebron 1929 & Gaza 2023: A Tale of Two Massacres

Kibbutz Be'eri after Oct. 7th
Kibbutz Be'eri after Oct. 7th. Tsafrir Abayov/AP

Long before Israel existed, Jewish families in Hebron were being murdered in their homes. The 1929 massacre, carried out under British rule, offers a stark historical reminder that anti-Jewish violence in the land predates Israel’s control of Judea and Samaria and Gaza by decades.

By Hezy Laing

In August 1929, Arab mobs stormed the ancient Jewish community of Hebron, murdering 67 Jews, including men, women and children. They broke into homes, attacked families and ransacked synagogues. There was no State of Israel, no Israel Defense Forces and no Israeli occupation of Judea and Samaria. Nearly a century later, the Hamas massacre of October 7, 2023, revealed disturbing parallels with that earlier bloodshed.

Some commentators portray the October 7 massacre as a response to Israeli policies, including the blockade of Gaza and the conflict over territory. But the history of Hebron demonstrates that murderous anti-Jewish violence in the land long predates the establishment of Israel in 1948 and its capture of Judea, Samaria and Gaza in 1967.

A Community Under Attack

For centuries, Hebron had been home to a Jewish community centered on religious study and the Tomb of the Patriarchs. In 1929, Jews lived there under British Mandate rule, alongside Arab neighbors. The community had no Jewish army or sovereign government to protect it.

Tensions escalated amid competing nationalist movements and religious incitement. False rumors spread that Jews intended to seize the Temple Mount and Al-Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem. On August 23, violence began in Hebron, and the following morning, a Saturday, mobs armed with knives, axes and clubs attacked Jewish homes.

Families barricaded their doors, while others sought refuge in the homes of neighbors they trusted. Attackers entered houses and killed residents, including children. Jewish property was looted, and synagogues were vandalized. By the end of the massacre, 67 Jews had been murdered and many others wounded.

One of the most tragic episodes took place in the home of Eliezer Dan Slonim, a respected community leader who sheltered Jews fleeing the violence. When rioters demanded that he hand over the Jewish refugees, he refused. Slonim, his wife Hannah, their young son Aharon and others sheltering in the house were killed.

The surviving Jewish community was evacuated by the British authorities. Some families returned in 1931 and attempted to rebuild their lives, but renewed unrest led to another evacuation in 1936.

The Parallels with October 7

On October 7, 2023, Hamas-led terrorists crossed from Gaza into southern Israel, attacking communities and a music festival. They killed civilians in their homes, murdered entire families and abducted men, women and children into Gaza. The attacks left approximately 1,200 people dead and 251 hostages taken.

The two massacres occurred in different political circumstances, and their causes should not be treated as identical. But both involved attacks on Jewish civilians, violence inside homes and the use of incitement to turn Jews into targets. Both also raised a fundamental question: Can the bloodshed be explained solely as a reaction to the policies of the Israeli government?

The Hebron massacre took place 38 years before Israel captured Judea and Samaria and Gaza in the Six-Day War, and 19 years before the State of Israel was established. Its victims were members of an ancient Jewish community living under British rule, not citizens of a Jewish state enforcing a military occupation.

The Jews murdered in Hebron in 1929 were not protected by the IDF or surrounded by Israeli settlements. Their deaths cannot be explained as a response to Israel’s modern borders, military policies or blockade of Gaza.

Understanding the history does not mean ignoring later events or the political grievances that shape today’s conflict. It means recognizing that anti-Jewish violence in the land has a history that predates the modern State of Israel—and that any serious explanation of the conflict must reckon with that fact

2 Comments

  1. Max Braude

    October 7, 2026

    It goes back 1400 years not a hundred!

  2. Phyllis Klempner

    October 7, 2026

    Anyone who reads Middle East or Jewish history can confirm that. Trouble is that modern schooling doesn’t include much real history.

Leave a Reply

Thank You for joining

IDF News

Videos

Heroes

Weapons